The Cardboard Shelf
โ† Categories

Token & Component Upgrades

Metal coins, resource tokens, and bits trays that turn a good game into a tactile one.

Top picks
Byhoo 50 PCS Metal DND Coins, 1.2" Gold Silver Copper Tokens with Face Value for Board Game and Tabletop RPG, Fantasy Metal Coins for Pathfinder,Pirate Game Party Cosplay
Metal Coin Upgrade Set (assorted denominations)
Heavy, satisfying coins that replace flimsy cardboard money โ€” the most-loved component upgrade.
View on Amazon โ†’
Affiliate link โ€” as an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.
Luck Lab Board Game Token Trays, 6-Pack Folding Silicone Swirl Color Bowls
Bits Trays / Resource Token Cups (set)
Small stackable cups that keep meeples, cubes, and coins reachable and off the board.
View on Amazon โ†’
Affiliate link โ€” as an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.

Upgrades you'll actually notice

Metal coins are the classic first upgrade โ€” the weight changes how a game feels every turn, and they're the upgrade you handle most. Resource-shaped tokens (little wooden or acrylic goods) come next for economy games. The rule of thumb: the more often your hands touch a component, the more an upgrade is worth.

Rank upgrades by impact

Spend on what you touch, not what just sits on the board.

  • Metal coins โ€” handled every turn; highest impact.
  • Resource tokens and upgraded dice โ€” touched often; a solid second.
  • Deluxe meeples and figures โ€” mostly visual; lowest impact.

Keep upgrades reachable

Better components only help if they're not buried in a pile. Pair an upgrade set with small bits trays so each resource has a home within arm's reach of every player. Trays also speed up setup and teardown, since you lift the whole tray rather than scooping loose tokens.

Check the fit before you buy

Upgraded components are often bigger and heavier than the originals. Oversized metal coins or chunky tokens can stop the box lid closing or overflow the insert โ€” confirm the dimensions against your box first, especially for currency sets thicker than the cardboard they replace.

Frequently asked questions

Are metal coins worth it?

For a game you play often, yes โ€” coins are handled every turn, so the weight and sound noticeably improve the feel of economy and trading games. For rarely-played games the upgrade mostly sits in the box, so prioritize your most-played titles.

Which component upgrade should I buy first?

Start with metal coins, since they're the component you handle most. After that, upgraded resource tokens and dice give the next-biggest improvement. Deluxe meeples and figures look great but change the experience the least.

Read next